Why was Kane's penalty retaken against Croatia?

Harry Kane was able to give England the lead against Croatia from the penalty spot - but only thanks to the video assistant referee.

The spot-kick was awarded in the ninth minute after Luka Modric fouled Noni Madueke.

England captain Kane saw his first effort saved by Croatia goalkeeper Dominik Livakovic.

The VAR stepped in to give Kane a second chance because Livakovic was off his line.

At the time a kick is taken the keeper must have one foot on or above the line, and images showed that Livakovic had moved fractionally too soon.

But even if the keeper had stayed on his line, the penalty would still have been retaken.

After Livakovic made the save the loose ball dropped to Manchester City's Josko Gvardiol to clear for Croatia.

But he had also moved too quickly and was inside the area when Kane took his first attempt.

This is not an automatic retake, as the defender must impact an opposition attacker.

Madueke was behind Gvardiol, so by clearing the ball he prevented the Arsenal winger from getting a shot from the rebound.

Kane duly despatched at the second attempt.

Harry Kane was allowed a second chance to take his penalty after Dominik Livakovic left his line early

Croatia equalise again as England drawing 2-2 in thrilling World Cup opener

Interestingly, Kane had a similar penalty saved for Bayern Munich in the Champions League against Atalanta earlier this season.

Afterwards the forward said he had seen that the goalkeeper liked to come off his line, adding: "I knew that if I stopped, there was a good chance he'd come too far forward. And that's exactly what happened."

Following Kane's penalty against Croatia, former Three Lions defender Conor Coady told 5 Live: "He can take any sort of penalty. He is that good at penalties.

"That is really clever if that is something he is thinking of, if he is watching other keepers and how they move and what they do, that is a really clever thing to do.

"He must've practiced, he's obviously looked at the keeper."

Former Spurs and England goalkeeper Paul Robinson added: "It has worked for him. The goalkeeper has come off his line but the interesting thing is he stuck to that technique for the next one.

"I have seen him do it this season before and I think his confidence and where he's at at the moment, you can't question him.

"The actual strike of the penalty was too close to the goalkeeper. Even if the goalkeeper hadn't tried to seek the advantage he would have still saved it.

"You look at the way he learned from the first penalty, was brave enough to go the same way and this one was much closer to the corner. He'll have practised many penalties going into this tournament."

Play BBC Sport's new World Cup predictor game

World Cup fixtures and group standings

How to watch the World Cup on the BBC

Everything you need to know about the World Cup